Put Baby to Sleep in the Best Crib Mattress

Put Baby to Sleep in the Best Crib Mattress

Sleep is critical for your baby’s development, health, and well-being, which means it is crucial to have a safe, comfortable place for your child to rest. The foundation of great baby sleep is a high quality crib mattress partnered with the perfect crib. The goal is to find the best crib mattress that will last until your child needs a toddler bed. 

One thing is for sure, getting a used mattress can lead to all sorts of harmful problems for your new baby. Everything from a dust mite infestation, busted seams, or even foul odor from the previous owner are possibilities that you simply don’t want to deal with. Save yourself the hand-me-down hassle. Investing in the best crib mattress and crib sheets will guarantee your little one a heavenly night sleep every night!


There are three things that are essential when it comes to buying the best crib mattress: comfort, affordability, and resistance to liquids and “accidents”. However, it can be difficult to find a mattress with all three of those things at your local store. Luckily, we’ve done the scouting for you and have found five of the best crib mattresses your little boy or girl deserves.

Best Crib Mattress Reviews

My First Premium Memory Foam

Best baby/toddler mattress you will ever find!” -Alyssa

  • Hypoallergenic, anti-microbial
  • Removable, washable cover
  • Under $100

This soft-as-can-be bed from My First Premium has everything you need to call it the best crib mattress out there and it’s one of the cheapest on the market.

The My First Premium is made with premium polyurethane foam that is CertiPUR-US certified. Not only is it comfortable to sleep on, but the best part about the memory foam mattress is that it’s quiet – the bed won’t squeak or scratch as your baby moves throughout the night, unlike other spring based beds. It is also very resistant to sagging.

This mattress protects against dust mites, is anti-microbial, hypoallergenic, and has zero lead or phthalate. It even comes with its own removable, waterproof mattress cover that is machine washable, which is perfect for your little ones who aren’t potty trained yet. The My First Premium fits standard cribs and is available under $100. We couldn’t recommend this mattress enough.









  • Memory Foam could be too stiff
  • Doesn’t fit snug in some cribs
Colgate Eco Classica III w/ Organic Cotton Cover

Best crib mattress I have found for my newborn.” -Meaghan

  • Organic Cover
  • Eco-Friendly
  • Double-Sided Firmness

While there are many good baby crib mattress companies around, perhaps none out-do Colgate in overall attention to detail.

Colgate prides itself in passing the toughest GREENGUARD standard for indoor air quality. The mattress contains over 10,000 organic compounds and is completely chemical free. Speaking of organic, the Colgate Eco Classica III also comes with a certified organic cotton cover. Doctors recommend firm mattresses for infants, which is why this mattress provides dual firmness – an extra firm side for your infants safety, and then a slightly less firm side for your toddlers comfort.

Colgate wraps up their eco-friendly offer with a lifetime warranty. If you want the best organic crib mattress and have two hundred dollars to spend, there is no compromise.


  • Around $200
  • Might smell a little bit when new
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core

I love this mattress and so does my son! He sleeps better and longer.” -Jennifer

  • crafted with USA-based soybean oils
  • waterproof cover
  • Women’s Choice Award for 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016.

From America’s best brand for babies comes our number three mattress – the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core. As with the My First Premium, this Sealy mattress is GREENGUARD certified for low chemical emissions and air quality.

It’s is an extra firm mattress, yet it’s lightweight, crafted with USA-based soybean oils. The waterproof cover is pearl-embossed for super simple cleaning. 

The mattress sports perfectly square corners. Why is this important? Well it ensures that fitted sheet and crib sheet fit snugly, and the mattress itself is a snug and safe fit into your crib.  It is safest when the sheets, mattress, and crib fit together perfectly, with no gaps. Safety 1st!

With their high-quality material and logical design, there’s no wonder Sealy mattresses have won the Women’s Choice Award for 2013, 2014, 2015, and 2016.


  • Cover has a plastic feel
  • Might smell a little bit when new
Dream On Me 4"

Have used this since my daughter was 6 weeks old and still love it a year and a half later.” -Penelope

  • Hypoallergenic
  • Antibacterial
  • Flame Retardant

The Dream on Me 4” is an option for those who want a comfy, good mattress at a more affordable price. The mattress is made with hypo-allergenic and anti-bacterial material, and it has a reversible design with a bear print on one side and a soft white cloud print on the other.

The Dream On Me is soundproof, passes federal flammability tests (flame-retardant), and is standard size. The bed is also designed to wipe clean easily without mold or odors.

One thing to keep in mind is that some of these crib mattresses may not come with a cover pad. This can be bad news if you forgot to order one, but great news if you remember that you can purchase a really nice organic bed pad for less than twenty dollars. 

  • Cover isn’t removable
  • Has a plastic feel without sheets on
Sealy Perfect Rest

Great mattress for a 2 year old. He slept better the very first night using this mattress” -Lesli

  • 10 Year Warranty
  • Tear Resistant Cover
  • Air Flow pockets for circulation

The Sealy Perfect Rest is made with 150 heavy-gauge coils and border rods that keep the whole package equally firm, from the edges to the center.

There’s a tear-resistant crib mattress cover that helps prevent stains and mildew. The Sealy Perfect Rest sports air flow pockets to circulate air and keep the mattress cool. And in the unlikely event that anything happens to the mattress, Sealy has you covered with a durable 10 year warranty.

If you want a safe, comfortable mattress for your baby, and you aren’t a fan of memory foam, this might be the crib mattress for you. We recommend you top it off with the best organic crib mattress sheet for your little one.



  • Cover isn’t removable
  • Needs waterproof cover

Conclusion on the Best Crib Mattress

So there you have it, the five best crib mattresses.

If you’re on a budget, consider getting one of the cheaper mattresses like the Dream on Me with an organic protector pad and sheet on top. If your main concern is comfort, go with the My First Premium or the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core. And if you want to go all out, Colgate Eco Classica III will not disappoint.

Any one of these choices will be sure to lull even the most stubborn baby right to sleep. If you still have problems after you picked out the perfect crib mattress, maybe you should check out some of our tips for when your little one just can’t sleep or even invest in a good nightlight.

“This is the only newsletter   I actually want to read


We hear this from our subscribers over and over again. Join the 1,000’s of parents just like you and figure out why.

  • 1 Email per week. No Spam. Period.
  • Things Parents want to Read About
  • Subscriber Exclusive Content
  • Giveaways and Contests
00
Days
00
Hours
20
Minutes
32
Seconds